|
Spam Menace
Eliminate Spam before it gets to your mail server
Perhaps no problem plagues the Internet as deeply
as that of unsolicited junk E-mail, or Spam. While it is quite
annoying to end users, spam robs your company of productivity and of
system resources and it can be a nightmare for both network
administrators and for those who own or manage a company. By
Renuka Vembu
|
"Current
anti-spam solutions fall into four primary slabs —filters,
reverse lookups, challenges, and cryptography. Each of these
solutions offers some relief to the spam problem, but they
also have significant limitations"
- Vikas Desai Lead
Technology Consultant, India and SAARC, RSA, The Security
Division of EMC |
|
"Deploying an anti-spam solution will prevent
unsolicited e-mail but it requires expertise on anti-spam
technology, proper configuration of the server and knowledge
of the Mail eXchange record (MX) and DNS. It will increase the
administrative control and resource utilization that is
required to manage an anti-spam solution"
- Sekhar
Dash Manager, Offsite Delivery, SecureSynergy |
|
"A
business can either deploy an appliance or software within
its network to weed out spam before it is delivered to the
mail server or use Managed e-mail Security, wherein mail
gets filtered at the domain level on the Internet"
- Prashant
Mudbidri Director, Logix Consultancy Group Pvt.
Ltd. |
|
"Parameters like number of employees in the
organization using e-mail, number of messages per employee,
average size of a message, the kind of business are some of
the basic criteria that needed to be considered while trying
to map an application for any client"
- Kartik
Shahani Regional Director, McAfee India |
|
"Spam
clogs bandwidth, soaks up disk space, and slows servers, which
often forces businesses to increase their storage capacity
requirements. Smaller businesses working with minimal
bandwidth are especially feeling the increasing strain
that the spam is putting on their network"
- Prabhat Kumar
Singh Director, Symantec Response
Lab |
Today both individuals and companies agree that
spam is one of the biggest problems on the Internet these days. Mail
servers, networks and user inboxes are being overwhelmed by the
increasing incidence of spam, viruses, phishing frauds and other
unwanted e-mail, which is estimated to account for 70-90% of all
e-mail received. The Symantec Internet Security Threat Report XIII
states that during H2 2007, spam made up 71% of all e-mail traffic
monitored at the gateway, a 16% increase over the last six months of
2006. The report found that 80% of all spam detected during this
period was composed in English, up from 60% in the previous
reporting period. SecureSynergy reported that there was 100% growth
of spam last year. Global spam levels are increasing all the time,
hitting an all-time high of 95% of all e-mail sent during a peak in
the third quarter of 2007, with a scaling trend expected in 2008 and
2009 as well. IDC estimated that the size of business e-mail volumes
sent annually worldwide in 2007 was close to five exabytes, nearly
doubling over the past two years.
This constant flood of spam not only clogs
networks and adversely affects user inboxes, but also drains
valuable resources such as bandwidth and storage capacity and
interferes with the expedient delivery of legitimate emails
particularly in corporate set-ups. The administrative cost of
dealing with this flood of spam and other unwanted e-mail is
estimated to be as high as $800 per mailbox per year, resulting in a
total cost of billions of dollars per year in lost productivity.
An evolving menace
The definition of spam has undergone a drastic
change. Earlier, spam was defined as any mail, which was
unsolicited. This then moved to selling unacceptable stuff. Now spam
has malicious content that causes a computer to crash or contains
links and attachments, which gather confidential information,
without the user’s knowledge. Individual privacy as well as
corporate security is easily compromised, if spam floods the inbox.
Threat patterns have evolved over time and are blended today. The
evolving threats come in the form of viruses, malware, spam,
phishing and pharming and attack a network to steal information as
well as reduce application and system performance.
Not all spam is malicious; there are even genuine
messages, which are blocked because they are unsolicited. Trying
personally to figure out the possibility of a single relevant mail
in a heap of spam is tedious and time-consuming. Venu Palakirti,
Sales Director, India and SAARC Region/Director, F-Secure asserted,
“The challenge for corporations is putting a policy and process
around it rather than having to keep up with storage. The policy and
process would include how long do you want to keep the spam for, how
should you process a request to release an e-mail that ended up in
the spam repository, how do you categorize spam. No internal
mailing/distribution list should be allowed to receive e-mail from
external parties and so on.”
However, spam has a dark side—it amounts to an
increase in storage space, consumption of additional bandwidth,
waste of time and loss of productivity. New age spam comes with
heavy attachments in PDF format or JPEG files, thereby leading to
increased bandwidth usage and additional storage space being
consumed. Spammers have been designing new ways to evade spam
filters. Even with a hit rate is as low as 0.1%; spammers still have
a substantial effect as they send tens of thousands of messages out
into cyberspace. Spam can even enter through the medium of SMS, MMS,
video clips on mobile phones, through downloads and game trials,
etc.
Prabhat Kumar Singh, Director, Symantec Response
Lab, opined, “Spammers have been working feverishly to devise new
ways to evade spam filters. Today e-mail servers are now being
flooded with image-based spam that looks like text-based spam, but
consists of one or more images in order to defeat traditional spam
filtering technology. This means that, more than ever, spam clogs
bandwidth, soaks up disk-space, and slows servers, which often
forces businesses to increase their storage capacity requirements.”
Smaller businesses working with minimal bandwidth are especially
feeling the increasing strain that spam is putting on their network,
he added.
Different kinds of spam attacks
From mere marketing gimmicks advertising products,
to endorsing unacceptable content, to virus infiltration, spam has
evolved for the worse. According to Anand Iyer, President,
Marketing, Gajshield, there are different types of spam some of the
key ones being:
- Spam: Commercial and ideological
spam is sent in large quantities; spammers are able to match the
language to the country the spam is sent to. English spam is
considered the most widely internationally distributed
variant.
- Phishing and Vhishing (fraudulent
messages): Messages generated by criminals who seek to make a
quick buck by posing as banks, transaction-based Web sites (such
as eBay and PayPal) and lottery authorities (winning
notifications) fall under this category.
- DoES: Denial of E-mail Service
(DoES) attacks often originate from competition or protest. The
purpose of the inflictor is to cause the mail server to overflow
and cause it to reject further mail.
- Mail-bombing: The intention of a
mail-bombing initiator is to cause damage to an organization by
filling the mail server’s hard drives, choking the organization’s
bandwidth and slowing down the organization’s mail flow (causing
an attack similar to DoES).
- Trojan horses: They are generated
from competition and commonly used to steal competitive
information.
- Open relay exploit: The SMTP
protocol is old and buggy. Several exploits allow e-mail relay
even when a server has not been configured as an open relay
system. Spammers’ robots search for exploitable systems to use for
spam distribution.
Non Delivery receipt (NDR): Recently, there is a
growing phenomenon in which innocent recipients receive, on a daily
basis, an alarming volume of NDR notifications, which are generated
and sent from legitimate MTAs (Message Transfer Agents) that refuse
to forward spam messages to targeted victims. These NDR
notifications are sent back to the forged e-mail addresses in the
‘from’ address. While these NDR notifications are not spam, messages
they are annoying just the same.
Security risk
Vikas Desai, Lead Technology Consultant, India and
SAARC, RSA, The Security Division of EMC, categorized current
anti-spam solutions into four primary slabs—filters, reverse
lookups, challenges, and cryptography. Each of these solutions
offers some relief to the problem, but each has its own significant
limitations. Desai said that with spamming methods becoming
advanced, it poses significant security risks, which include:
- Identity theft: Phishing and other
frauds are distributed as spam, directly leading to identity theft
and fraud.
- Viruses: New viruses, worms,
Trojans and malware, such as Melissa, Love Bug, MyDoom, Black
Widow, etc., used spam techniques to propagate after being
triggered by the user.
- Combining exploits and spam: The
distinction between malicious hackers and spammers has become less
obvious. Many spammers have incorporated malicious code that
targets browser, HTML, and JavaScript vulnerabilities.
- Combining viruses and spam: It is
widely believed that some viruses are designed to assist spammers.
For example, the SoBig worm installed open proxies that were used
to relay spam. As spam becomes more prevalent, the use of malware
and spyware to support spam is likely to increase.
- Buying larger recycle bins for
junk mails
- Loss of private and
confidential data
- Legal issues that might arise
due to its content
- Loss of bandwidth, storage
space and resource wastage
- Updating system
requirements
Source: Microworld
Technologies |
Anti-spam deployments
To combat every threat, one needs sophisticated
tools, which evolve with changing times. Vendors need to make
solutions/design appliances that keep adapting themselves to the
client requirements and meeting new challenges just as the threats
get more serious. There is a need for end-to-end security.
Vendors suggest there were two different types of
anti-spam deployments available that suit business requirements:
- Desktop based anti-spam protection that
integrates with an e-mail client and tags the spam messages and
moves them to a designated spam folder. This is more suitable for
home users and users having small networks without a dedicated
e-mail server.
- Server based anti-spam, which is
installed on the e-mail server itself. It blocks incoming spam
messages to all the mail-boxes at the server level. This
protection is best suited for users having a large network and a
dedicated e-mail server to send and receive e-mail. Here putting
the anti-spam solution on the server is the most logical
option.
Sekhar Dash, Manager, Offsite Delivery,
SecureSynergy explained that deploying Anti-Spam solution will
prevent the delivery of unsolicited e-mail, but it requires
expertise in Anti-Spam technology, proper configuration of server
and knowledge of Mail eXchange records (MX) and DNS. This will
increase the administrative control and resource utilization
required to manage an anti-spam solution. Sometimes genuine mail is
quarantined or blocked due to poor configuration of an anti-spam
solution. Organizations can choose either to install the anti-spam
software or hardware to protect the e-mail server or outsource the
task to a Managed Security Services (MSS) provider. In MSS the spam
and malicious content is blocked before it reaches an organization’s
gateway or mail server. Outsourcing to a Managed Security Services
provider not only reduce the organization’s resource utilization but
also save the time and bandwidth utilization.
Source:
Logix Consultancy Group Pvt. Ltd.
|
As per Prashant Mudbidri, Director, Logix
Consultancy Group Pvt. Ltd., there are primarily two solution sets
available to combat spam:
- A premise or in-house solution, wherein
you deploy the appliance or software within your network to weed
out spam before it is delivered to the mail server.
- The Outsourced Model, popularly known as
Managed E-mail Security, wherein mail is filtered at the domain
level on the Internet and what comes in is only clean mail; even
the outbound route gets treated the same.
Iyer explained, “New virus distribution methods
designed to thwart signature-based anti-virus technology are on the
rise. These include ‘short span attacks’, serial variant attacks and
attacks launched from botnets. Today’s viruses, worms, Trojans and
malware target the primary weakness in anti-virus technology: the
time it takes for new signatures or heuristics to be developed and
distributed. The result is that customers are without protection for
the critical initial period of 12-20 hours when the spread of the
viruses or worms is the highest and are bound to get infected by
viruses during this time frame.”
- Accuracy of spam
filtering
- Accuracy of virus and new virus
outbreak filtering
- False positive ratios
(legitimate mails trapped as spam)
- Quarantine management
- End-user access and release
functionality of false positive mails
- Future proofing
- Mail tracking
- Redundancy
- High availability, single point
failure
Source: Logix Consultancy
Group Pvt. Ltd. |
Designing an anti-spam solution
There are several parameters to be followed while
designing any product/ solution, which can be application software
or a network solution. Kartik Shahani, Regional Director, McAfee
India, said that parameters such as number of employees in the
organization using e-mail, the number of messages per employee,
average size of a message, the kind of business it is engaged in,
would give a fix on network traffic and this is required to map an
application for any client. He said that malware extrapolated to
phishing attacks, then to e-mail and voice.
Surendra Singh, Regional Director, SAARC and
India, Websense Inc, opined that hosted e-mail, which is adopted on
a wide basis internationally, would be the best answer to combat the
growing threat of spam. The primary challenge of formulating and
deploying any solution should scale as per the requirement, and
handle the workload. A virus creator does not stop at releasing his
creation into the wild. He comes up with variations of the same
virus, and hence anti-virus solutions have to updated constantly
with the latest patches or signatures.
Palakirti stated that functionality, usability and
security, were the three key aspects that an anti-spam solution had
to have. “The product must be able to function according to your
expectations and it should be user friendly enough, and most
importantly, it must be secure. Security should not be bolt on; it
must be built in and thought of from the very beginning when you are
designing the product,” he asserted.
Mahesh Gupta, Business Development Manager,
Network Security, Cisco India and SAARC, also added that
intelligence needs to be at the end-point, and segmenting the
network into multiple domains, with the monitoring and visibility
aspect given due prominence.
Dash opined that a combination of old and new
detection technologies would prevent spam. Spammers are using
Lexical text analysis method to bypass an anti-spam solution, which
examines the content of the e-mail and looks for strings of text
that can be interpreted as spam such as offers to purchase
something, offer to use services, solicitation to visit a Web site,
etc. It is based on lexical rules that include Boolean logic with
operators like OR, AND, NOT, etc. However, using the following
combination of techniques, spam can be reduced to the lowest
possible minimum and yet not block legitimate e-mail.
- Real-time black lists (RBL)
- Internal black lists
- DNS lookup
- Spoofed sender n Header analysis
- Mail-bombing prevention
- E-mail harvesting prevention
- Subject analysis
- Spam database
- Lexical text analysis
- Statistical text analysis
- Heuristic analysis
- Porn image detection
- Web Beacon detection
- Optical Character Recognition
(OCR)
Text manipulation detection
Issues to be addressed
Ram Kumar Balina, Director, Global IT Operations
and Information Security, Virtusa opined on the core issues that
need to be dealt with:
- Ensure that the product does not send
unsolicited mail, which could potentially be considered as
spam.
- Ensure the products do not publish
contact details of people that can be used for spreading
spam.
- The products do not communicate to any
public SMTP servers that could exploit the systems and end up
spreading spam.
- The product should be modular, to fix any
issues that could potentially be exploited for spreading
spam.
- Ensure that a team is available and that
it addresses any complaints from the customer.
Capt. Raghu Raman, CEO, Mahindra Special Services
Group (MSSG), explained that opportunity loss was one of the
principal concerns, as legitimate e-mail sometimes is caught in the
process.
Spam is a combination of unsolicited junk, harmful
content like contraband, pornography, or anything with a shade of
vulgarity, and malicious software. Capt. Raman firmly said that spam
was a behavioral problem. He was also optimistic that the problem
was a significant one affecting both government and industry alike;
and that by 2010, there will be action initiated against spammers.
He also stressed on solution like—strategic level initiatives,
collaborative initiative, and architecture enveloping several
layers.
Going by the suggestions and expert views, it is
recommended that more than products, organizations should plan
proper policies to handle spam, analyze their mail patterns and
conduct periodic reviews to reduce the menace of spam.
renuka.vembu@expressindia.com |